LEED TSAC PVC Study Database > Comments on Draft Report

Comments on Draft Report
Pages
Name/Organization/Comment
  
[<] 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 [>]
Comments 441-480 of 562.
Page(s) Lines(s) Submitter Organization Comment
77 13 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "The total life cycle mortality results are dominated by particulate exposures rather than c...
77 6-11 Judith Schreiber NYS Attorney General Office Section 3.3.6 Focus on Human Health misses the point. It needs another category to assess popula...
77 78 1-37 1-3 Douglas Wiegand Resilient Floor Covering Institute (RFCI) The section 3.3.6 side-by-side comparisons of risks from the four product groups is misleading be...
77,78,79 77-13 78-5 78-20 Erik Jansson Department of the Planet Earth Three Underlying Findings That Are Factually Incorrect, and Severely Bias the Particulate-Cancer ...
78 6 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "Occupational cancer risks dominate the population cancer risks posed by the life cycle rele...
7-9 Charlie Stephens Oregon Department of Energy The panel’s Findings are without adequate foundation. The data used is heavily weighted toward t...
7-9 Judith Schreiber NYS Attorney General Office Most of this section indicates greater problems associated with PVC than with non-PVC materials.
79-82 1 Wilma Subra Subra Company Conclusion: This section of the report is based on misinterpretations of the Kentucky Pollution P...
8 1-3 Jane Rohde JSR Associates, Inc. Recommend requesting from the Plastic Pipe Institute (www.plasticpipe.org) to provide information...
8 19-27 Don Hodges Hodges & Hodges Architects See comment above for occupational health costs of wood products.
8 37-43 Don Hodges Hodges & Hodges Architects See comment above for occupational health costs of wood products.
8 32-36 Laura Millberg Claiming that it is not important what material a window frame is made from because the energy ef...
8 31-43 Alan Olson Ferro Corp., Cleveland, OH As pointed out in the Windows summary, energy efficiency is the overwhelming factor among aluminu...
8 4 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "Aggregated health impacts of carcinogens as well as particulate emissions show that PVC and...
8 23 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network The report justifies virtually ignoring the meaning of 3 of the 10 studies on the particulate imp...
8 27 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "Cork has the lowest combined mortality impacts." Again there is at least one clearly b...
8 33 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "...the total life cycle results are not dominated by the frame material, but by the glazing...
8 33 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network It will again vary widely, again potentially by orders of magnitude by your climate, whether you ...
8 33 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network Finally it is not static in time. The fuel mix and many of the other factors listed here are chan...
80 1 Wilma Subra Subra Company The report states (80-15) “the dearth of data make conclusive predictions about ambient air conce...
80 17 Wilma Subra Subra Company The text indicates that because the data are old, the data cannot be used to determine if signifi...
80 8 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "a high spike was quickly corrected" On what reference does the task group know that th...
80 24 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "Mean concentrations of vinyl chloride in air over the entire published monitoring period we...
81 5 Wilma Subra Subra Company Comment: The Vinyl Chloride air concentrations for the selected monitoring stations in West Loui...
81 8 Wilma Subra Subra Company The report states that “data available for individual stations may be very sparse or not comprehe...
81 21 Wilma Subra Subra Company The report gives a tentative conclusion that the monitoring data did “not indicate exposures at t...
82 1 Wilma Subra Subra Company The Task Group concluded that the monitoring data did not indicate exposures of concern. Comme...
82 10 Wilma Subra Subra Company The text states “when 2004 sampling data are made available...” Comment: The 2004 data is av...
82 35 Wilma Subra Subra Company “For the years monitored, 24-hour samples were generally taken every 5-6 days throughout the year...
82 26 Wilma Subra Subra Company Westlake data Vinyl Chloride data is evaluated, but the Ethylene Dichloride data is not. Evaluati...
82 18 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "Air monitoring data …tabulated ...by Sage Environmental Consulting, Inc. were provided by t...
83 4 Wilma Subra Subra Company “The data ...indicate that although the AAS was exceeded on an annual average basis at both monit...
83 18 Wilma Subra Subra Company The South Scotlandville Monitoring station “showed much more frequent daily exceedances of the AA...
83 21-23 Frank Borrelli The Vinyl Institute We agree with your analysis of the Air Monitoring Data for VCM at Lighthouse and South Scotlandvi...
84 14 Michael McHugh E. Verner Johnson and
Associates		 The report notes, and even highlights, acknowledgement that the public is at a significant healt...
84 8 Wilma Subra Subra Company Trace Atmospheric Gas Analyzer (TAGA) Data for Louisiana “The highest frequency of detects ...
84 25 Wilma Subra Subra Company The report states that “The TAGA data provide a glimpse of environmental conditions in 1999, but ...
84 14 Tom Lent Healthy Building Network "Consistent exposure of individual to these concentrations may indeed pose a significant hea...
85 18 Jonathan Herz General Services Administration Here, and in many other places (e.g., page 93, line 21), disclaimers weaken the conclusions.
85-87 John Stuart Occidental International Corp. TSAC has correctly analyzed the cancer mortality data for Louisiana, and placed the allegations a...